It’s been a while since I’ve read the books, so forgive me if I’m missing something. But I thought Harry wasn’t sure if there was an afterlife. He even expresses doubt whether the “afterlife” conversation is something he’s just imagining in his head.
Also, I think that argument proves too much: it would apply to every soldier, terrorist, freedom fighter, activist, and martyr who believes in an afterlife. Even if you intellectually believe there’s an afterlife (or even if you intellectually believe your sacrifice is right) it’s still difficult to overcome the instinct to stay alive.
Uneel guvaxf gung gur nsgreyvsr pbairefngvba jvgu Qhzoyrqber zvtug or va uvf urnq. Ohg ur qbrfa’g guvax gung gur pbairefngvba cevbe gb gung jvgu gur Erfheerpgvba Fgbar jurer ur gnyxf gb Wnzrf, Yvyl, Fvevhf, Yhcva vf va uvf urnq. Vg frrzf gb or gnxra sbe tenagrq nf erny. Gura, Uneel znxrf uvf fnpevsvpr naq gura orpnhfr bs gung fnpevsvpr vf noyr gb pbzr onpx.
Also, I think that argument proves too much: it would apply to every soldier,
terrorist, freedom fighter, activist, and martyr who believes in an afterlife. Even if
you intellectually believe there’s an afterlife (or even if you intellectually believe your > sacrifice is right) it’s still difficult to overcome the instinct to stay alive.
True, but Harry’s certainty in an afterlife is much higher than that of any of those people, and his certainty about the nature of the afterlife is also much higher. Moreover, he’s been specifically told that death isn’t a big deal. Fvevhf says that it is a smooth transition.
If someone is that certain about the afterlife and the nature of the afterlife, then it does substantially reduce the heroism of such sacrifices.
Heck, even if you were absolutely completely certain that a decent afterlife awaits you, martyrdom still mean getting the shaft. The afterlife and whatever it may offer will be waiting for you indefinitely and will presumably last a long, long time, whereas once you give up on your earthly life’s experiences there’s no getting them back.
It’s been a while since I’ve read the books, so forgive me if I’m missing something. But I thought Harry wasn’t sure if there was an afterlife. He even expresses doubt whether the “afterlife” conversation is something he’s just imagining in his head.
Also, I think that argument proves too much: it would apply to every soldier, terrorist, freedom fighter, activist, and martyr who believes in an afterlife. Even if you intellectually believe there’s an afterlife (or even if you intellectually believe your sacrifice is right) it’s still difficult to overcome the instinct to stay alive.
I’m rereading that section now. ROT13ed:
Uneel guvaxf gung gur nsgreyvsr pbairefngvba jvgu Qhzoyrqber zvtug or va uvf urnq. Ohg ur qbrfa’g guvax gung gur pbairefngvba cevbe gb gung jvgu gur Erfheerpgvba Fgbar jurer ur gnyxf gb Wnzrf, Yvyl, Fvevhf, Yhcva vf va uvf urnq. Vg frrzf gb or gnxra sbe tenagrq nf erny. Gura, Uneel znxrf uvf fnpevsvpr naq gura orpnhfr bs gung fnpevsvpr vf noyr gb pbzr onpx.
True, but Harry’s certainty in an afterlife is much higher than that of any of those people, and his certainty about the nature of the afterlife is also much higher. Moreover, he’s been specifically told that death isn’t a big deal. Fvevhf says that it is a smooth transition.
If someone is that certain about the afterlife and the nature of the afterlife, then it does substantially reduce the heroism of such sacrifices.
Heck, even if you were absolutely completely certain that a decent afterlife awaits you, martyrdom still mean getting the shaft. The afterlife and whatever it may offer will be waiting for you indefinitely and will presumably last a long, long time, whereas once you give up on your earthly life’s experiences there’s no getting them back.