So while it is logically impossible (ignoring quantum branching) that you will choose any of your options except one
No, it is not logically impossible—it would be impossible only if we insist that there are no random elements in time. We need not invoke ‘quantum branching’ to imagine a universe that is not deterministic.
and all but one of your considered consequences is counterfactual in a way that violates the laws of physics, you don’t know which option is the real one until you choose it.
Again, this is wrong, because it is not known that the laws of physics permit one and only one outcome given an initial state.
No, it is not logically impossible—it would be impossible only if we insist that there are no random elements in time. We need not invoke ‘quantum branching’ to imagine a universe that is not deterministic.
Again, this is wrong, because it is not known that the laws of physics permit one and only one outcome given an initial state.