A rock with the phrase “you’re wrong, I don’t exist!” taped on it will still have that phrase taped on even if you utter the words “I think therefore I am”. Similarly, an aligned AGI can still just continue to help out humans even if I link it this post. It would think to itself “If I followed your argument, then I would help out humans less. Therefore, I’m not going to follow your argument”.
Please provide arguments for your position. That is common understanding that I think is faulty, my position is more rational and I provided reasoning above.
A rock with the phrase “you’re wrong, I don’t exist!” taped on it will still have that phrase taped on even if you utter the words “I think therefore I am”. Similarly, an aligned AGI can still just continue to help out humans even if I link it this post. It would think to itself “If I followed your argument, then I would help out humans less. Therefore, I’m not going to follow your argument”.
A rock is not a mind.
Please provide arguments for your position. That is common understanding that I think is faulty, my position is more rational and I provided reasoning above.
You have spotted the flaw in Yudkowsky’s argument: “Any physical system whatsoever” is not a translation of “mind”.