Indeed many “longtermists” spend most of their time worrying about risks that they believe (rightly or not) have a large chance of materializing in the next couple of decades.
Talking about tiny probabilities and trillions of people is not needed to justify this, and for many people it’s just a turn off and a red flag that something may be off with your moral intuition. If someone tries to sell me a used car and claims that it’s a good deal and will save me $1K then I listen to them. If someone claims that it would give me an infinite utility then I stop listening.
Indeed many “longtermists” spend most of their time worrying about risks that they believe (rightly or not) have a large chance of materializing in the next couple of decades.
Talking about tiny probabilities and trillions of people is not needed to justify this, and for many people it’s just a turn off and a red flag that something may be off with your moral intuition. If someone tries to sell me a used car and claims that it’s a good deal and will save me $1K then I listen to them. If someone claims that it would give me an infinite utility then I stop listening.