This post claims: Claim-tagging is worth trying more broadly
steph
I think the saying is “clear beliefs weakly held”, not “strong beliefs weakly held”.
I think this claim’s title is too long to be used a handle for the concept.
I need some explanatory text before I can vote on this.
I think it is important. I now want to refine the claim.
I don’t understand the graph, can someone explain it to me?
Paul’s recent post argues in favor of this position: https://arbital.com/p/6mt/
I’d update toward this position if I saw a good reason to expect you’ve gotten it more right than others.
In particular, I would disagree with the claim if “our community” means “all the people who are fans of the sequences” and I would agree if it means “silicon valley”
Also I think we want a basic argument instead of a bunch of links to related claims.
It’s not operationalized enough for me to vote.
I think it’s important for claims to be very clear, and that this one isn’t clear enough.
This claim is making want a “wrong question” button.
What does “our community” mean?
What if it was tagged with claims? Would that give you what you’re wanting from a summary? I feel much more able to tag a post with claims than I am able to write a summary of the post.
Can you give me an example of a page where the editor slows down substantially? I want to make sure I’m reproducing the correct thing.