Dumbledore has argued that death is good. We have all assumed that this meant he thought death is good. I’m beginning to question that assumption. Dumbledore’s stated belief has given him access to the Philosopher’s Stone, and resulted in Voldemort going to the Mirror with a specific state of mind. Both of those are very useful conditional on Dumbledore considering death to be bad.
Admittedly, he probably didn’t predict the second one, but it’s entirely possible that Dumbledore had been claiming that death was great for his whole life in hopes that one day the holder of the Philosopher’s Stone would give it to him for safe keeping.
Dumbledore has argued that death is good. We have all assumed that this meant he thought death is good. I’m beginning to question that assumption. Dumbledore’s stated belief has given him access to the Philosopher’s Stone, and resulted in Voldemort going to the Mirror with a specific state of mind. Both of those are very useful conditional on Dumbledore considering death to be bad.
Admittedly, he probably didn’t predict the second one, but it’s entirely possible that Dumbledore had been claiming that death was great for his whole life in hopes that one day the holder of the Philosopher’s Stone would give it to him for safe keeping.