It seems to me that the heart of Pascal’s mugging is the question of whether the universe is much bigger than I think it is. If there’s a good chance of that, then I should prioritize exploration over exploitation (if I have an unbounded utility function). An agent that claims to be able to exploit the big universe doesn’t really make the problem worse.
Given a few additional assumptions, such as the life of the agent being indefinite, I would agree. However, that doesn’t give you a reason to reject the muggers offer (I don’t think), it just gives you an incentive to explore.
It seems to me that the heart of Pascal’s mugging is the question of whether the universe is much bigger than I think it is. If there’s a good chance of that, then I should prioritize exploration over exploitation (if I have an unbounded utility function). An agent that claims to be able to exploit the big universe doesn’t really make the problem worse.
Given a few additional assumptions, such as the life of the agent being indefinite, I would agree. However, that doesn’t give you a reason to reject the muggers offer (I don’t think), it just gives you an incentive to explore.