I’m unsure what you’re either expecting or looking for here.
There does seem to be a clear answer, though—just look at Bing chat and extrapolate. Absent “RL on ethics,” present-day AI would be more chaotic, generate more bad experiences for users, increase user productivity less, get used far less, and be far less profitable for the developers.
Bad user experiences are a very straightforwardly bad outcome. Lower productivity is a slightly less local bad outcome. Less profit for the developers is an even-less local good outcome, though it’s hard to tell how big a deal this will have been.
I’m unsure what you’re either expecting or looking for here.
There does seem to be a clear answer, though—just look at Bing chat and extrapolate. Absent “RL on ethics,” present-day AI would be more chaotic, generate more bad experiences for users, increase user productivity less, get used far less, and be far less profitable for the developers.
Bad user experiences are a very straightforwardly bad outcome. Lower productivity is a slightly less local bad outcome. Less profit for the developers is an even-less local good outcome, though it’s hard to tell how big a deal this will have been.