Since this post was written, I feel like there’s been a zeitgeist of “Distillation Projects.” I don’t know how causal this post was, I think in some sense the ecosystem was ripe for a Distillation Wave) But it seemed useful to think about how that wave played out.
Some of the results have been great. But many of the results have felt kinda meh to me, and I now have a bit of a flinch/ugh reaction when I see a post with “distillation” in it’s title.
Basically, good distillations are a highly skilled effort. It’s sort of natural to write a distillation of something as part of your attempt to understand it, and upskill (I think I had previously advocated this sometimes). I think this was basically a reasonable thing to do, but, it did have the cumulative effect of decreasing the signal-noise ratio of distillations, since most people doing this aren’t skilled yet.
None of that contradicts the claims of this post, which specify various skills you need, and recommends actually investing in those skills. (The title of this post is “call for Distillers”, not “call for Distillations”. I think a lot of what happened was things like “Distillation contests”, and incorporating distillation into SERI MATS programming, etc, which doesn’t automatically produce dedicated distillers)
Since this post was written, I feel like there’s been a zeitgeist of “Distillation Projects.” I don’t know how causal this post was, I think in some sense the ecosystem was ripe for a Distillation Wave) But it seemed useful to think about how that wave played out.
Some of the results have been great. But many of the results have felt kinda meh to me, and I now have a bit of a flinch/ugh reaction when I see a post with “distillation” in it’s title.
Basically, good distillations are a highly skilled effort. It’s sort of natural to write a distillation of something as part of your attempt to understand it, and upskill (I think I had previously advocated this sometimes). I think this was basically a reasonable thing to do, but, it did have the cumulative effect of decreasing the signal-noise ratio of distillations, since most people doing this aren’t skilled yet.
None of that contradicts the claims of this post, which specify various skills you need, and recommends actually investing in those skills. (The title of this post is “call for Distillers”, not “call for Distillations”. I think a lot of what happened was things like “Distillation contests”, and incorporating distillation into SERI MATS programming, etc, which doesn’t automatically produce dedicated distillers)