… Er, but now that seems to be gone and I don’t even see any record of my edits. Perhaps I needed to do something different on account of the page having been deleted. (I just visited the page with redirect=no or redirect=off or whatever it is, edited its contents to replace the magic #REDIRECT[[Delete]] or whatever it was, and saved—was that wrong?)
Anyway, it looks as if Gleb has now recreated the page again, so it exists but is rather one-sidedly promotional.
[EDITED to add:] No, wait, I was seeing an old cached version. I think the wiki must be serving up pages with misleading cache-control headers or something. I think it’s all OK.
Try doing control-f5 to force a full reload of the page. Until I did that, I found that I saw “my” version when logged in and Gleb’s version when logged out. I think I saw weird behaviour in the histories too, but I forget exactly what.
I’m using Safari on a Mac, so ctrl-F5 isn’t a meaningful keystroke. Trying a different browser that I’ve never accessed these pages before with gave the same behaviour. That browser (Firefox) has ctrl-shift-R for a forced reload, and that made the wiki pages for the article itself show your version. However, the history and discussion pages weren’t up to date, until I did more forced reloads.
Now even more weirdness is happening. In Firefox, if I force-reload https://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Intentional_Insights, I get the latest version. If I do an ordinary reload, I get Gleb’s old version. Force reload—new. Ordinary reload—old. I have never seen this behaviour before. Clearly something is wrong somewhere, but what?
Back in Safari, I cleared all history and cookies. Same behaviour as before: one URL gets Gleb’s old version, one gets your version. This happens whether I’m logged in or out.
I see that the history has a few minor edits by Gleb around 06:38, 1 December 2015. UDT right now is 22:53, 30 November 2015. What timezone does the wiki run on?
by taking the old ININ page and renaming it “delete” it took the history over there to a page named “delete”.
Assuming gleb made a new inin page; that would be a second set of history. and be making a mess of the wiki in general.
Nothing fancy; probably not purposefully done to hide the edit history; rather probably done to add permanence to the action of trying to delete the page (and had the effect of messing with the edit history as well)
I think argument for you editing the wiki on InIn to correct gjm’s version is much better than the argument for Gleb editing the wiki on InIn; there’s a reason Wikipedia has a rule against autobiographies outside of user pages.
… Er, but now that seems to be gone and I don’t even see any record of my edits. Perhaps I needed to do something different on account of the page having been deleted. (I just visited the page with redirect=no or redirect=off or whatever it is, edited its contents to replace the magic #REDIRECT[[Delete]] or whatever it was, and saved—was that wrong?)
Anyway, it looks as if Gleb has now recreated the page again, so it exists but is rather one-sidedly promotional.
[EDITED to add:] No, wait, I was seeing an old cached version. I think the wiki must be serving up pages with misleading cache-control headers or something. I think it’s all OK.
This is rather strange. If I go to https://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Intentional_Insights, I see Gleb’s last version. If I go to https://wiki.lesswrong.com/index.php?title=Intentional_Insights, I see gjm’s version. However, clicking on the history tab of the latter page lists no edits since Gleb’s of 19 November.
On the “Delete” page, the history at https://wiki.lesswrong.com/index.php?title=Delete&action=history shows a third attempt by VoiceofRa at 18:49 on 30 November 2015 (timezone unspecified but probably UDT) to delete the InIn material.
There seems to be some sort of inconsistency in the wiki. VoiceofRa’s misuse of redirection does not help.
Try doing control-f5 to force a full reload of the page. Until I did that, I found that I saw “my” version when logged in and Gleb’s version when logged out. I think I saw weird behaviour in the histories too, but I forget exactly what.
I’m using Safari on a Mac, so ctrl-F5 isn’t a meaningful keystroke. Trying a different browser that I’ve never accessed these pages before with gave the same behaviour. That browser (Firefox) has ctrl-shift-R for a forced reload, and that made the wiki pages for the article itself show your version. However, the history and discussion pages weren’t up to date, until I did more forced reloads.
Now even more weirdness is happening. In Firefox, if I force-reload https://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Intentional_Insights, I get the latest version. If I do an ordinary reload, I get Gleb’s old version. Force reload—new. Ordinary reload—old. I have never seen this behaviour before. Clearly something is wrong somewhere, but what?
Back in Safari, I cleared all history and cookies. Same behaviour as before: one URL gets Gleb’s old version, one gets your version. This happens whether I’m logged in or out.
I see that the history has a few minor edits by Gleb around 06:38, 1 December 2015. UDT right now is 22:53, 30 November 2015. What timezone does the wiki run on?
looks like this happened:
by taking the old ININ page and renaming it “delete” it took the history over there to a page named “delete”.
Assuming gleb made a new inin page; that would be a second set of history. and be making a mess of the wiki in general.
Nothing fancy; probably not purposefully done to hide the edit history; rather probably done to add permanence to the action of trying to delete the page (and had the effect of messing with the edit history as well)
Thank you.
Thanks for figuring this out, all! I have little wiki editing experience, so this is quite helpful knowledge.
You need to stop editing that article, GJM had it to a good place.
I think GJM was too harsh.
http://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2005/12/16/i-have-the-power
I think argument for you editing the wiki on InIn to correct gjm’s version is much better than the argument for Gleb editing the wiki on InIn; there’s a reason Wikipedia has a rule against autobiographies outside of user pages.
NancyLebovitz made a post about it here, so you can share your perspective there.