I’d be worried about evaporative cooling. It seems that the net result of this would be that labs would be almost completely devoid of people earnest about safety.
I agree with you government pathways to impact are most plausible and until recently undervalued. I also agree with you there are weird competitive pressures at labs.
I do think evaporative cooling is a concern, especially if everyone (or a very significant amount) of people left. But I think on the margin more people should be leaving to work in govt.
I also suspect that a lot of systemic incentives will keep a greater-than-optimal proportion of safety-conscious people at labs as opposed to governments (labs pay more, labs are faster and have less bureaucracy, lab people are much more informed about AI, labs are more “cool/fun/fast-paced”, lots of govt jobs force you to move locations, etc.)
I also think it depends on the specific lab– EG in light of the recent OpenAI departures, I suspect there’s a stronger case for staying at OpenAI right now than for DeepMind or Anthropic.
I’d be worried about evaporative cooling. It seems that the net result of this would be that labs would be almost completely devoid of people earnest about safety.
I agree with you government pathways to impact are most plausible and until recently undervalued. I also agree with you there are weird competitive pressures at labs.
I do think evaporative cooling is a concern, especially if everyone (or a very significant amount) of people left. But I think on the margin more people should be leaving to work in govt.
I also suspect that a lot of systemic incentives will keep a greater-than-optimal proportion of safety-conscious people at labs as opposed to governments (labs pay more, labs are faster and have less bureaucracy, lab people are much more informed about AI, labs are more “cool/fun/fast-paced”, lots of govt jobs force you to move locations, etc.)
I also think it depends on the specific lab– EG in light of the recent OpenAI departures, I suspect there’s a stronger case for staying at OpenAI right now than for DeepMind or Anthropic.