Sure, but I still maintain that a request for clarification itself can be annoying and hence downvote worthy. I don’t think any comment is inherently protected or should be exempt from being downvoted.
I agree with you on these points. I downvote requests for clarification sometime—particularly if, say, the reason for the downvote is transparent or the flow conveys an attitude that jars with me. I certainly agree that people should be free to downvote freely whenever they please and for whatever reason they please—again, for me to presume otherwise would be a demand for naivety or dishonesty (typically both).
I agree with you on these points. I downvote requests for clarification sometime—particularly if, say, the reason for the downvote is transparent or the flow conveys an attitude that jars with me. I certainly agree that people should be free to downvote freely whenever they please and for whatever reason they please—again, for me to presume otherwise would be a demand for naivety or dishonesty (typically both).