trend (up/down): Up/Down—if indicated by the OP to be used that way—though I agree that messes with the karma system
checkmark: missing
Reflecting a bit more on it, I think my original excitement must have clouded my judgment: I no longer think that the mapping is obvious or even halfway clear.
I love it.
I reviewed my voting proposal and see my suggestions covered except for the checkmark suggestion.
I read through your proposal, and I don’t understand how all your suggestions are covered. Can you run through which of your proposed elements
lightbulb: is used for surprising or insightful information
exclamation mark: is used to warn about something that requires attention
question mark: flags open questions that should be answered
trend (up/down): information about a general positive/negative trend
checkmark: Different from an up-vote; indicates that something was completed and does not need further attention
you see as corresponding to which elements in the current setup?
lightbulb: surprise
exclamation mark: Skepticism or Hits the Mark
question mark: Seeks Truth
trend (up/down): Up/Down—if indicated by the OP to be used that way—though I agree that messes with the karma system
checkmark: missing
Reflecting a bit more on it, I think my original excitement must have clouded my judgment: I no longer think that the mapping is obvious or even halfway clear.