idea threads where the highest comment has more votes than the thread itself (i.e. a crappy idea)
It depends—if the higher-voted comments are expending on the original post, then I’d say the post was successful because it evoked good-quality thought, assuming that the voters have good judgement. If the higher-voted comments are refuting the original post, then it was probably a bad post.
It depends—if the higher-voted comments are expending on the original post, then I’d say the post was successful because it evoked good-quality thought, assuming that the voters have good judgement. If the higher-voted comments are refuting the original post, then it was probably a bad post.