I’m interested in what you have to say, and I’m sympathetic (I think), but I was hoping you could restate this in somewhat clearer terms. Several of your sentences are rather difficult to parse, like “And to be committed to false statements as being not-false would be absurd, such that it would alone be proper to aver that one has been defeated in having previously been committed to the truth of T despite that that committment was fundamentally invalid.”
Read my latest comments. If you need further clarity, ask me specific questions and I will attempt to accommodate them.
But to give some additional note on the quote you provide, look to reductio ad absurdum as a case where it would be incorrect to aver to the truth of what is really contradictory in nature.
If it still isn’t clear, ask yourself this: “does it make sense to say something is true when it is actually false?” Anyone who answers this in the affirmative is either being silly or needs to have their head checked (for some fascinating stuff, indeed).
I’m interested in what you have to say, and I’m sympathetic (I think), but I was hoping you could restate this in somewhat clearer terms. Several of your sentences are rather difficult to parse, like “And to be committed to false statements as being not-false would be absurd, such that it would alone be proper to aver that one has been defeated in having previously been committed to the truth of T despite that that committment was fundamentally invalid.”
Read my latest comments. If you need further clarity, ask me specific questions and I will attempt to accommodate them.
But to give some additional note on the quote you provide, look to reductio ad absurdum as a case where it would be incorrect to aver to the truth of what is really contradictory in nature. If it still isn’t clear, ask yourself this: “does it make sense to say something is true when it is actually false?” Anyone who answers this in the affirmative is either being silly or needs to have their head checked (for some fascinating stuff, indeed).