Not entirely sure, though I believe I did post a couple of comments to Overcoming Bias a while back. I used to comment on reddit and comment semi-regularly on Hacker News, which refutes the first explanation that I thought of, that it was a matter of my time, since clearly I do sometimes take time to comment on the internet.
The comments here are high quality, which is somewhat intimidating, and also makes things take longer, since I want to think more carefully about what I say, but that would probably apply to Hacker News as well.
A possible explanation consistent with the quotation I mentioned is that even though I read all the posts here and on Overcoming Bias, I don’t think I’ve thought about the issues deeply enough to have much original to contribute. And that may have something to do with the fact that most of my friends aren’t all that interested in the topics. I imagine if I were talking about the posts more often in real life I would feel like I had more to contribute.
I’m in a similar situation—I comment (sometimes) on reddit and HNews, and have occasionally posted a few sentences to OB, but I am much less likely to comment here. The high quality of the posts and comments leads me to agonize a bit overmuch about every part of a comment, and sometimes I will write, edit, and rewrite a comment before deciding to just not comment at all. I, too, often feel I would not be contributing anything original.
(I should also note in this comment that I am male.)
Well, I’m female and I agree with what you say. I often get the feeling that I’m barely well-read enough to follow a conversation here, and the comments I make are only on side-issues, or ones that I have experience of from “the outside” (eg IT or on being female).
I’ve made a few witty quips and minor points elsewhere… but they really aren’t part of a full discussion.
I get the feeling that I am a complete and total novice (not a problem), and that I need to have at least read all the way through all the sequences (million words or thereabouts wasn’t it?) before I can even get around a lot of the nuances brought up by the other commenters… and if I try posting before then, I’ll get it wrong, get some rather swift kicks in the premises (which are a downer even if well-intended) and feel less likely to stick my neck out the next time...
there’s an awfully steep learning curve here, and it feels very hard to break in unless you’re still suffering from serious overconfidence bias ;)
I lurked on lesswrong for about a year, because I used to be worried about losing karma and looking like an idiot. I guess I got used to it after enough terrific failures. If you want to appear consistently intelligent, this is a very hard site to do it on (even after you do the research)
I feel absolutely the same way but contribute it partly to having english as only second language. Although I am told to have a better grasp of it than most of my english-speaking peers, the high-level-concepts and language need a lot more time, and formulating original, coherent answers is even harder. I am male.
Any idea why you haven’t?
Not entirely sure, though I believe I did post a couple of comments to Overcoming Bias a while back. I used to comment on reddit and comment semi-regularly on Hacker News, which refutes the first explanation that I thought of, that it was a matter of my time, since clearly I do sometimes take time to comment on the internet.
The comments here are high quality, which is somewhat intimidating, and also makes things take longer, since I want to think more carefully about what I say, but that would probably apply to Hacker News as well.
A possible explanation consistent with the quotation I mentioned is that even though I read all the posts here and on Overcoming Bias, I don’t think I’ve thought about the issues deeply enough to have much original to contribute. And that may have something to do with the fact that most of my friends aren’t all that interested in the topics. I imagine if I were talking about the posts more often in real life I would feel like I had more to contribute.
I’m in a similar situation—I comment (sometimes) on reddit and HNews, and have occasionally posted a few sentences to OB, but I am much less likely to comment here. The high quality of the posts and comments leads me to agonize a bit overmuch about every part of a comment, and sometimes I will write, edit, and rewrite a comment before deciding to just not comment at all. I, too, often feel I would not be contributing anything original.
(I should also note in this comment that I am male.)
Well, I’m female and I agree with what you say. I often get the feeling that I’m barely well-read enough to follow a conversation here, and the comments I make are only on side-issues, or ones that I have experience of from “the outside” (eg IT or on being female).
I’ve made a few witty quips and minor points elsewhere… but they really aren’t part of a full discussion.
I get the feeling that I am a complete and total novice (not a problem), and that I need to have at least read all the way through all the sequences (million words or thereabouts wasn’t it?) before I can even get around a lot of the nuances brought up by the other commenters… and if I try posting before then, I’ll get it wrong, get some rather swift kicks in the premises (which are a downer even if well-intended) and feel less likely to stick my neck out the next time...
there’s an awfully steep learning curve here, and it feels very hard to break in unless you’re still suffering from serious overconfidence bias ;)
I lurked on lesswrong for about a year, because I used to be worried about losing karma and looking like an idiot. I guess I got used to it after enough terrific failures. If you want to appear consistently intelligent, this is a very hard site to do it on (even after you do the research)
I feel absolutely the same way but contribute it partly to having english as only second language. Although I am told to have a better grasp of it than most of my english-speaking peers, the high-level-concepts and language need a lot more time, and formulating original, coherent answers is even harder. I am male.