It’s funny because I would argue the exact same thing from the opposite side of the aisle. If you take someone who identifies with memory, internal speech, and internal image and reports nothing else, they don’t seem all that conscious to me. Consider the moment directly before and after going lucid in a dream.
Come to think of it, I wonder if ‘lucid’ dreaming would even be a sensible distinction for a q-zombie.
It’s funny because I would argue the exact same thing from the opposite side of the aisle. If you take someone who identifies with memory, internal speech, and internal image and reports nothing else, they don’t seem all that conscious to me. Consider the moment directly before and after going lucid in a dream.
Come to think of it, I wonder if ‘lucid’ dreaming would even be a sensible distinction for a q-zombie.