I am personally finding both interesting to read, even though it is hard to hold both sides in my head at once. I would encourage the participants to keep hashing it out insofar as you yourselves are finding it somewhat productive! Distillation can come later.
(I may have an ulterior motive here of being excited in general to see people try to hash out major disagreements using the dialogues format, I am cheering this on to succeed...)
I am personally finding both interesting to read, even though it is hard to hold both sides in my head at once. I would encourage the participants to keep hashing it out insofar as you yourselves are finding it somewhat productive! Distillation can come later.
(I may have an ulterior motive here of being excited in general to see people try to hash out major disagreements using the dialogues format, I am cheering this on to succeed...)