You are giving examples of people telling that other people’s lives are not worth living. That doesn’t mean those other people agreed with them.
Imagine today a very rich person saying “if you are not a millionaire, you should kill yourself, because your life is too miserable”. Would you accept it as evidence that lives of non-millionaires are worse than death?
Imagine today a very rich person saying “if you are not a millionaire, you should kill yourself, because your life is too miserable”. Would you accept it as evidence that lives of non-millionaires are worse than death?
It’s some evidence, although I agree very weak. I think the evidence I gave was importantly different in two ways, making this type of citation relevant. One, these are accomplished philosophers who gave extensive reasoning to back up their theses. Two, unlike today where you can literally just read what ordinary people have to say about this issue, few ordinary people in the 18th century were literate and wrote that type of thing down. Therefore, we need to rely on reports from other people who could write things down, who happened to disproportionately be the wealthy elite.
You are giving examples of people telling that other people’s lives are not worth living. That doesn’t mean those other people agreed with them.
Imagine today a very rich person saying “if you are not a millionaire, you should kill yourself, because your life is too miserable”. Would you accept it as evidence that lives of non-millionaires are worse than death?
It’s some evidence, although I agree very weak. I think the evidence I gave was importantly different in two ways, making this type of citation relevant. One, these are accomplished philosophers who gave extensive reasoning to back up their theses. Two, unlike today where you can literally just read what ordinary people have to say about this issue, few ordinary people in the 18th century were literate and wrote that type of thing down. Therefore, we need to rely on reports from other people who could write things down, who happened to disproportionately be the wealthy elite.