I don’t think our positions are very different on this. Like I said to Morendil and JGW, the fact that this is a good question for discussion makes it belong on the site—but in Open Thread. In its top-level form, it needs to do a more thorough handling of the topic.
I don’t think our positions are very different on this.
Yes, I was expressing a similar position, so included it here to reduce clutter.
I wonder why the grandparent was downvoted. It wasn’t particularly controversial position. Presumably either because it was in reply to your comment so someone voted systematically, assuming it was a fundamental disagreement (other replies to your comment were downvoted at some stage) or because of a parenthetical confession that I too downvoted the post (although I’d expect more umbrage to be taken at your burn!)
I don’t think our positions are very different on this. Like I said to Morendil and JGW, the fact that this is a good question for discussion makes it belong on the site—but in Open Thread. In its top-level form, it needs to do a more thorough handling of the topic.
Yes, I was expressing a similar position, so included it here to reduce clutter.
I wonder why the grandparent was downvoted. It wasn’t particularly controversial position. Presumably either because it was in reply to your comment so someone voted systematically, assuming it was a fundamental disagreement (other replies to your comment were downvoted at some stage) or because of a parenthetical confession that I too downvoted the post (although I’d expect more umbrage to be taken at your burn!)