I would say it was, but only because you managed to include elements of the speculation while still thinking of plots and turns that I did not see speculated. With the amount of speculation I participated in, it felt like an excellent emotional roller coaster, which I will try to describe with a few anecdotal sentences.
“Yes, that idea has been referenced!”
“Yes, that idea has been referenced as well! Multiple points, I knew it, I was expecting multiple points to come up, I should have posted that instead of remaining silent.”
“Oh, I should have seen that! In hindsight it feels like could have guessed that.”
“Wait, THAT wasn’t the true answer?”
“Wait, WHAT? I never would have guessed this!”
“He’s surprised, but it made perfect sense!”
“Heehee, he even referenced that as well!”
But it seems like it was only that good because you managed to narrowly outwit the amount of effort I had to put into it and the amount of collective thought I had taken the time to read. I feel like if I had been speculating to an overly large extent that I wouldn’t have been able to consider it as a story, but that if I hadn’t been speculating at all I wouldn’t have gotten the twists and turns it was taking.
So while I personally would vote for this option, I think I can see several reasons why it wouldn’t necessarily work for other people in the same way it did for me, assuming I’m right about my mental pictures of other readers.
Vote up if you think that the experience of reading the chapter was better for all the speculation.
I would say it was, but only because you managed to include elements of the speculation while still thinking of plots and turns that I did not see speculated. With the amount of speculation I participated in, it felt like an excellent emotional roller coaster, which I will try to describe with a few anecdotal sentences.
“Yes, that idea has been referenced!” “Yes, that idea has been referenced as well! Multiple points, I knew it, I was expecting multiple points to come up, I should have posted that instead of remaining silent.” “Oh, I should have seen that! In hindsight it feels like could have guessed that.” “Wait, THAT wasn’t the true answer?” “Wait, WHAT? I never would have guessed this!” “He’s surprised, but it made perfect sense!” “Heehee, he even referenced that as well!”
But it seems like it was only that good because you managed to narrowly outwit the amount of effort I had to put into it and the amount of collective thought I had taken the time to read. I feel like if I had been speculating to an overly large extent that I wouldn’t have been able to consider it as a story, but that if I hadn’t been speculating at all I wouldn’t have gotten the twists and turns it was taking.
So while I personally would vote for this option, I think I can see several reasons why it wouldn’t necessarily work for other people in the same way it did for me, assuming I’m right about my mental pictures of other readers.