Exactly! Instead of this being a generic discussion of how maybe you can get the romantic utilons you want from more than one person, suddenly it’s about the conflict between the educated man’s logical evolutionarily dictated interest being directed towards multiple concubines, and the irrational woman’s investment in marriage, imposed upon her by society. The shot’s composition itself supports this, with the man clearly on top by virtue of more than just being naturally taller.
Is all this Luke’s intent? Well, I’d like to think not, especially given his comments about trying to reduce the perception of misogynistic tones in the piece. But as he is a heterosexual man (yes? as far as I’ve been able to tell Luke’s not bisexual or at least didn’t present that way during the time period of these stories, please correct me if I’m wrong) Luke’s story doesn’t deviate from these norms, and the picture is definitely reinforcement.
Would an actual photo of Luke and Alice be better?
Now I’m imagining a picture of Luke with a redacted silhouette of a woman entitled “woman I am not attracted to any more”. There are arrows pointing to various lacking physical attributes lacking from an evolutionary psychology perspective, complete with sketches of what they should look like… Perhaps with a supplemental craziness vs hotness chart or two.
Okay, this would actually be really epic and I would support it assuming it didn’t have the whole fracking white background creating cutouts thing going on.
I think this could easily lead to an outside observer interpreting this very negatively. I believe the relevant vague catch-all term is “objectifying”. The entire approach of a silhouette for the female and an actual picture for the male could easily send very negative signals to a lot of people.
Color me marginalized.
Exactly! Instead of this being a generic discussion of how maybe you can get the romantic utilons you want from more than one person, suddenly it’s about the conflict between the educated man’s logical evolutionarily dictated interest being directed towards multiple concubines, and the irrational woman’s investment in marriage, imposed upon her by society. The shot’s composition itself supports this, with the man clearly on top by virtue of more than just being naturally taller.
Is all this Luke’s intent? Well, I’d like to think not, especially given his comments about trying to reduce the perception of misogynistic tones in the piece. But as he is a heterosexual man (yes? as far as I’ve been able to tell Luke’s not bisexual or at least didn’t present that way during the time period of these stories, please correct me if I’m wrong) Luke’s story doesn’t deviate from these norms, and the picture is definitely reinforcement.
Would an actual photo of Luke and Alice be better?
Now I’m imagining a picture of Luke with a redacted silhouette of a woman entitled “woman I am not attracted to any more”. There are arrows pointing to various lacking physical attributes lacking from an evolutionary psychology perspective, complete with sketches of what they should look like… Perhaps with a supplemental craziness vs hotness chart or two.
Okay, this would actually be really epic and I would support it assuming it didn’t have the whole fracking white background creating cutouts thing going on.
I think this could easily lead to an outside observer interpreting this very negatively. I believe the relevant vague catch-all term is “objectifying”. The entire approach of a silhouette for the female and an actual picture for the male could easily send very negative signals to a lot of people.
Agreed, but the idea still made me laugh :)