Yeah, to be clear, I don’t think everything Simplicio says is obviously wrong, and I think a more interesting (and much longer) version of this dialogue would have tried harder to understand and steelman various Simplicio-models, regardless of whether it ended up siding against Simplicio.
Yeah, to be clear, I don’t think everything Simplicio says is obviously wrong, and I think a more interesting (and much longer) version of this dialogue would have tried harder to understand and steelman various Simplicio-models, regardless of whether it ended up siding against Simplicio.