Some time in the next week I’ll write up a post with a few full examples (including the one from Robins, Hernan and Wasserman), and explain in a bit more detail.
I look forward to reading it. To be honest: Knowing these authors, I’d be surprised if you have found an error that breaks their argument.
We are now discussing questions that are so far outside of my expertise that I do not have the ability to independently evaluate the arguments, so I am unlikely to contribute further to this particular subthread (i.e. to the discussion about whether there exists an obvious and superior Bayesian solution to the problem I am trying to solve).
I look forward to reading it. To be honest: Knowing these authors, I’d be surprised if you have found an error that breaks their argument.
We are now discussing questions that are so far outside of my expertise that I do not have the ability to independently evaluate the arguments, so I am unlikely to contribute further to this particular subthread (i.e. to the discussion about whether there exists an obvious and superior Bayesian solution to the problem I am trying to solve).