As soon as you start saying things like people need “to break their trust in a sane world, before which nothing can begin”, you know you have a problem.
Deciding the world is completely untrustworthy after learning that Santa Claus is a lie seems like the wrong update to make. The right update to make seems to be “adults sometimes lie to kids to entertain themselves and the kids”. In fact, arguably society tells you more incorrect info as a kid than as an adult, so you should become more and more trusting of what society tells you the older you grow. (Well, I guess you also get smarter as you grow, so it’s a bit more complicated than that.)
Deciding the world is completely untrustworthy after learning that Santa Claus is a lie seems like the wrong update to make. The right update to make seems to be “adults sometimes lie to kids to entertain themselves and the kids”.
It would be even better to update in the direction of understanding the interaction between social status, belief, affiliation and dominance.
In fact, arguably society tells you more incorrect info as a kid than as an adult, so you should become more and more trusting of what society tells you the older you grow. (Well, I guess you also get smarter as you grow, so it’s a bit more complicated than that.)
The parenthetical is correct. The ‘arguable’ part is true only in as much as it is technically possible to argue for most things that are stupid.
You should become more trusting in the sense that what adults tell you constitutes stronger Bayesian evidence, but your own thoughts will also constitute stronger Bayesian evidence.
You should become more trusting in the sense that what adults tell you constitutes stronger Bayesian evidence, but your own thoughts will also constitute stronger Bayesian evidence.
Adults also have more incentive to lie and deceive you when your decisions have enough power to influence their outcomes.
For example, you may be talking to a child whose parents are still lying to him.
Deciding the world is completely untrustworthy after learning that Santa Claus is a lie seems like the wrong update to make. The right update to make seems to be “adults sometimes lie to kids to entertain themselves and the kids”. In fact, arguably society tells you more incorrect info as a kid than as an adult, so you should become more and more trusting of what society tells you the older you grow. (Well, I guess you also get smarter as you grow, so it’s a bit more complicated than that.)
It would be even better to update in the direction of understanding the interaction between social status, belief, affiliation and dominance.
The parenthetical is correct. The ‘arguable’ part is true only in as much as it is technically possible to argue for most things that are stupid.
You should become more trusting in the sense that what adults tell you constitutes stronger Bayesian evidence, but your own thoughts will also constitute stronger Bayesian evidence.
Adults also have more incentive to lie and deceive you when your decisions have enough power to influence their outcomes.