That is a mistranslation. The original reads “do not murder”, i.e. do not kill extrajudicially.
Also, it’s 10 commandments not commendments :) God was apparently not overly pleased with his chosen people, certainly not enough to commend them 10 ways on the exodus well done.
I hear it was actually closer to “do not engage in blood feud”, but I don’t recall where I heard that so treat it with deep suspicion. In any case, one could add “unless you’re God” to these physical laws for the same effect.
(Wait, if God kills you, isn’t that still extrajudicial? God isn’t working for the government.)
(Wait, if God kills you, isn’t that still extrajudicial? God isn’t working for the government.)
Not really. Divine judgement qualifies for two out of three definitions of judicial right of the bat and then we have to consider that for religious purposes everyone is considered to either belong to a Theocracy under God or be a heathen enemy of the state. On top of that God’s scriptures dedicate much of their content to setting up a legal system, with a book outright dedicated to “Judges”. If it wasn’t for the fact that God just doesn’t exist I think it’d be fair to say that he claimed precedence on “Judicial” a long time back and human states just borrow the concept.
That is a mistranslation. The original reads “do not murder”, i.e. do not kill extrajudicially.
Also, it’s 10 commandments not commendments :) God was apparently not overly pleased with his chosen people, certainly not enough to commend them 10 ways on the exodus well done.
I hear it was actually closer to “do not engage in blood feud”, but I don’t recall where I heard that so treat it with deep suspicion. In any case, one could add “unless you’re God” to these physical laws for the same effect.
(Wait, if God kills you, isn’t that still extrajudicial? God isn’t working for the government.)
Not really. Divine judgement qualifies for two out of three definitions of judicial right of the bat and then we have to consider that for religious purposes everyone is considered to either belong to a Theocracy under God or be a heathen enemy of the state. On top of that God’s scriptures dedicate much of their content to setting up a legal system, with a book outright dedicated to “Judges”. If it wasn’t for the fact that God just doesn’t exist I think it’d be fair to say that he claimed precedence on “Judicial” a long time back and human states just borrow the concept.
You know, you’re right.