My work on converting The Useful Idea of Truth into a video is going well. I didn’t successfully anticipate the time that would be necessary to finish, but things are getting done at an acceptable pace. The best thing I can say, for sure, is that the overall style and presentation of the work has come a nice way forward since the start of this project, especially after working in some of the suggestions and impressions I’ve gotten from people.
(Included here is a short GIF of one of the recent portions that I’m particularly fond of, so additional criticism and suggestions for improvement are especially welcome.)
Typing just criticism because typing on tablet: the text seems to site to appear very slowly, and I become instantly frustrated because I can’t read it at normal speed
Hm. That would make sense, though it would make it no less frustrating for me. Perhaps it would make it better to use a style similar to the “Minute Physics” videos, where not every spoken word is shown.
Or present each sentence as a whole when the speaker starts saying it. (Reading is more “chunky” than listening; a single fixation of the eyes may take in multiple words. Or conceivably only part of a really long word. So presenting exactly one word at a time is rather weird.)
That’s fantastic advice, and it’s made me realize a lesson in gradually adapting my design decisions.
My original plans included (mostly) kinetic typography with the occasional visual aid. The elaborate style used for presenting the text was the main mechanic for capturing attention and differentiating it from an audiobook. As work was being done, however, I started adding more visualizations, and making the visualizations more compelling, more the point of focus, and otherwise moving into animating scenarios than animating words. The text, to not distract from what was now the focus of the video, has been becoming much more closed captioning than than anything else, and I hadn’t realized that until now.
I may or may not incorporate a more “chunky” presentation of words in this video (mostly because the thought of going back through what I have already and changing it is a daunting task, and negative-reinforcement for ever completing this thing at all), but I’m happy to say it’s something that now exists in my possible design space, and will definitely be a consideration for future videos.
Just as a heads-up (now that I’m typing on a real keyboard), I’m glad that you’re taking the time to illustrate/animate these concepts, and overall I really like the part that I’ve seen. Thanks for the good work so far, and I hope that you keep going with it.
The final product will be 720x1280, so hopefully that isn’t a significant problem. I’ll try and keep wider kerning/spacing in mind as I move forward, though. Thank you for the feedback!
My work on converting The Useful Idea of Truth into a video is going well. I didn’t successfully anticipate the time that would be necessary to finish, but things are getting done at an acceptable pace. The best thing I can say, for sure, is that the overall style and presentation of the work has come a nice way forward since the start of this project, especially after working in some of the suggestions and impressions I’ve gotten from people.
(Included here is a short GIF of one of the recent portions that I’m particularly fond of, so additional criticism and suggestions for improvement are especially welcome.)
Typing just criticism because typing on tablet: the text seems to site to appear very slowly, and I become instantly frustrated because I can’t read it at normal speed
I think that’s the speed it’s being spoken aloud.
Hm. That would make sense, though it would make it no less frustrating for me. Perhaps it would make it better to use a style similar to the “Minute Physics” videos, where not every spoken word is shown.
Or present each sentence as a whole when the speaker starts saying it. (Reading is more “chunky” than listening; a single fixation of the eyes may take in multiple words. Or conceivably only part of a really long word. So presenting exactly one word at a time is rather weird.)
That’s fantastic advice, and it’s made me realize a lesson in gradually adapting my design decisions.
My original plans included (mostly) kinetic typography with the occasional visual aid. The elaborate style used for presenting the text was the main mechanic for capturing attention and differentiating it from an audiobook. As work was being done, however, I started adding more visualizations, and making the visualizations more compelling, more the point of focus, and otherwise moving into animating scenarios than animating words. The text, to not distract from what was now the focus of the video, has been becoming much more closed captioning than than anything else, and I hadn’t realized that until now.
I may or may not incorporate a more “chunky” presentation of words in this video (mostly because the thought of going back through what I have already and changing it is a daunting task, and negative-reinforcement for ever completing this thing at all), but I’m happy to say it’s something that now exists in my possible design space, and will definitely be a consideration for future videos.
Just as a heads-up (now that I’m typing on a real keyboard), I’m glad that you’re taking the time to illustrate/animate these concepts, and overall I really like the part that I’ve seen. Thanks for the good work so far, and I hope that you keep going with it.
My first impression is that the text looks very cramped—it would probably be very difficult to read from far away.
The final product will be 720x1280, so hopefully that isn’t a significant problem. I’ll try and keep wider kerning/spacing in mind as I move forward, though. Thank you for the feedback!