Show me a field where replication crises tear through, exposing fraud and rot and an emperor that never had any clothes, a field where replications fail so badly that they result in firings and polemics in the New York Times and destroyed careers- and then I will show you a field that is a little confused but has the spirit and will get there sooner or later.
So… parapsychology? How’d that work out? Did they have the (ahem) spirit and get there sooner or later?
Personally I am quite pleased with the field of parapsychology. For example, they took a human intuition and experience (“Wow, last night when I went to sleep I floated out of my body. That was real!”) and operationalized it into a testable hypothesis (“When a subject capable of out of body experiences floats out of their body, they will be able to read random numbers written on a card otherwise hidden to them.”) They went and actually performed this experiment, with a decent deal of rigor, writing the results down accurately, and got an impossible result- one subject could read the card. (Tart, 1968.) A great deal of effort quickly went in to further exploration (including military attention with the men who stare at goats etc) and it turned out that the experiment didn’t replicate, even though everyone involved seemed to genuinely expect it to. In the end, no, you can’t use an out of body experience to remotely view, but I’m really glad someone did the obvious experiments instead of armchair philosophizing.
So… parapsychology? How’d that work out? Did they have the (ahem) spirit and get there sooner or later?
Personally I am quite pleased with the field of parapsychology. For example, they took a human intuition and experience (“Wow, last night when I went to sleep I floated out of my body. That was real!”) and operationalized it into a testable hypothesis (“When a subject capable of out of body experiences floats out of their body, they will be able to read random numbers written on a card otherwise hidden to them.”) They went and actually performed this experiment, with a decent deal of rigor, writing the results down accurately, and got an impossible result- one subject could read the card. (Tart, 1968.) A great deal of effort quickly went in to further exploration (including military attention with the men who stare at goats etc) and it turned out that the experiment didn’t replicate, even though everyone involved seemed to genuinely expect it to. In the end, no, you can’t use an out of body experience to remotely view, but I’m really glad someone did the obvious experiments instead of armchair philosophizing.
https://digital.library.unt.edu/ark:/67531/metadc799368/m2/1/high_res_d/vol17-no2-73.pdf is a great read from someone who obviously believes in the metaphysical, and then does a great job designing and running experiments and accurately reporting their observations, and so it’s really only a small ding against them that the author draws the wrong larger conclusions in the end.