The ideal attitude for humans with our peculiar mental architecture probably is one of “everything is amazing, also lets make it better” just because of how happiness ties into productivity. But that would be the correct attitude regardless of the actual state of the world. There is no such thing as an “awesome” world state, just a “more awesome” relation between two such states. Our current state is beyond the wildest dreams of some humans, and hell incarnate in comparison to what humanity could achieve. It is a type error to say “this state is awesome;” you have to say “more awesome” or “less awesome” compared to something else.
Also, such behavior is not compatible with the quote. The quote advocates ignoring real suboptimal sections of the world and instead basking how much better the world is than it used to be. How are you supposed to make the drinks better if you’re not even allowed to admit they’re not perfect? I could, with minor caveats, get behind “things are great lets make them better” but that’s not what the quote said. The quote advocates pretending that we’ve already achieved perfection.
There is no such thing as an “awesome” world state, just a “more awesome” relation between two such states.
Sure. But “things are pretty awesome” is faster to say than “our current world is more awesome than most of the worlds that have existed in history”.
The quote advocates pretending that we’ve already achieved perfection.
That’s a valid interpretation of the quote, but not the only one. The way I read it, specifically the way it focused on the drinks and the word “complain”, it wasn’t so much saying that we should pretend that we’ve already achieve perfection but rather to keep in mind what’s worth feeling upset over and what isn’t. In other words, don’t waste your time complaining about drinks to anyone who could hear, but instead focus your energies on something that you can actually change and which actually matters.
The ideal attitude for humans with our peculiar mental architecture probably is one of “everything is amazing, also lets make it better” just because of how happiness ties into productivity. But that would be the correct attitude regardless of the actual state of the world. There is no such thing as an “awesome” world state, just a “more awesome” relation between two such states. Our current state is beyond the wildest dreams of some humans, and hell incarnate in comparison to what humanity could achieve. It is a type error to say “this state is awesome;” you have to say “more awesome” or “less awesome” compared to something else.
Also, such behavior is not compatible with the quote. The quote advocates ignoring real suboptimal sections of the world and instead basking how much better the world is than it used to be. How are you supposed to make the drinks better if you’re not even allowed to admit they’re not perfect? I could, with minor caveats, get behind “things are great lets make them better” but that’s not what the quote said. The quote advocates pretending that we’ve already achieved perfection.
Sure. But “things are pretty awesome” is faster to say than “our current world is more awesome than most of the worlds that have existed in history”.
That’s a valid interpretation of the quote, but not the only one. The way I read it, specifically the way it focused on the drinks and the word “complain”, it wasn’t so much saying that we should pretend that we’ve already achieve perfection but rather to keep in mind what’s worth feeling upset over and what isn’t. In other words, don’t waste your time complaining about drinks to anyone who could hear, but instead focus your energies on something that you can actually change and which actually matters.