Presumably, any guy out there who is actually going through a reasoning process like what you describes also assumes that all women are lesbians, no? I mean, if they really can’t imagine how anyone could find this girl unattractive, it follows not only that aliens are attracted to her, but that human women are as well.
But it isn’t clear to me that everyone who makes this error also assumes that all women are lesbians.
Therefore it seems there’s something going on besides this sort of argument from incredulity.
Wait, what?
Presumably, any guy out there who is actually going through a reasoning process like what you describes also assumes that all women are lesbians, no? I mean, if they really can’t imagine how anyone could find this girl unattractive, it follows not only that aliens are attracted to her, but that human women are as well.
But it isn’t clear to me that everyone who makes this error also assumes that all women are lesbians.
Therefore it seems there’s something going on besides this sort of argument from incredulity.