Consequentialism tells us that the thing to do is the thing with the best results. But, this is a ridiculously high standard, that nobody can actually live up to. Thus, consequentialism tells us that everybody is bad, and we should all condemn everybody and all feel guilty.
In these scenarios I like point out that the other party is using an appeal to consequences as the justification for rejecting consequentialism.
In these scenarios I like point out that the other party is using an appeal to consequences as the justification for rejecting consequentialism.