I wanna flag the distinction between “deep” and “profound”. They might both be subject to the same bias you articulate here, but I think they have different connotations, and I think important ideas are systematically more likely to be “deep” than they are likely to be “profound.” (i.e. deep ideas have a lot of implications and are entangled with more things than ‘shallow’ ideas. I think profound tends to imply something like ‘changing your conception of something that was fairly important in your worldview.’)
I wanna flag the distinction between “deep” and “profound”. They might both be subject to the same bias you articulate here, but I think they have different connotations, and I think important ideas are systematically more likely to be “deep” than they are likely to be “profound.” (i.e. deep ideas have a lot of implications and are entangled with more things than ‘shallow’ ideas. I think profound tends to imply something like ‘changing your conception of something that was fairly important in your worldview.’)
i.e. profound is maybe “deep + contrarian”
Hm, yeah that seems like a relevant and important distinction.