I believe this post is one of the best to grace the front page of the LW forum this year. It provides a reasoned counterargument to prevailing wisdom in an accessible way, and has the potential to significantly update views. I would strongly support pinning this post to the front page to increase critical engagement.
I believe this post is one of the worst to appear the front page of the LW forum this year. Its research has gaping holes, and that anyone experienced in the area knows that those holes contain multiple factors that each negate and double-negate the conclusion, and has the potential to singlehandedly convert LW from an island of truth to one of the most catastrophic misinformation engines ever built. I would strongly support banning, condemning, and publicly distancing LW and rationalism from the OP in order to minimize the risk that this will ever happen again.
I believe this post is one of the best to grace the front page of the LW forum this year. It provides a reasoned counterargument to prevailing wisdom in an accessible way, and has the potential to significantly update views. I would strongly support pinning this post to the front page to increase critical engagement.
I believe this post is one of the worst to appear the front page of the LW forum this year. Its research has gaping holes, and that anyone experienced in the area knows that those holes contain multiple factors that each negate and double-negate the conclusion, and has the potential to singlehandedly convert LW from an island of truth to one of the most catastrophic misinformation engines ever built. I would strongly support banning, condemning, and publicly distancing LW and rationalism from the OP in order to minimize the risk that this will ever happen again.