I agree the effect is consistent enough that we should be suspicious of file drawer/p-hacking—although that’s also what you’d expect to see if the effect were in fact large—but note that they were different studies, i.e. the human studies mostly weren’t based on the non-human ones.
I agree the effect is consistent enough that we should be suspicious of file drawer/p-hacking—although that’s also what you’d expect to see if the effect were in fact large—but note that they were different studies, i.e. the human studies mostly weren’t based on the non-human ones.