I don’t know that shminux has inadvertently endorsed A and ~A. I’m suspicious that this has occurred because he resists the standard physical realist definition of territory / reality, but responds to a quasi-anti-realist position with an physical realist answer that I suspect depends on the rejected definition of reality.
If I knew precisely where the contradiction was, I’d point it out explicitly. But I don’t, so I can’t.
I don’t know that shminux has inadvertently endorsed A and ~A. I’m suspicious that this has occurred because he resists the standard physical realist definition of territory / reality, but responds to a quasi-anti-realist position with an physical realist answer that I suspect depends on the rejected definition of reality.
If I knew precisely where the contradiction was, I’d point it out explicitly. But I don’t, so I can’t.
Yeah, fair enough, I don’t think I understand his position myself at this point…