A more realistic and rational outcome: Alice is indeed an ass and it’s not fun to be around her. Bob walks out and blocks her everywhere. Now, dutchbook this!
In most contexts, yes. However, in the sort of dath ilanian context I was going for, or even in the context of a serious group of rationalists in our universe who are longtime friends, I don’t think what you described is a more realistic or rational outcome.
A more realistic and rational outcome: Alice is indeed an ass and it’s not fun to be around her. Bob walks out and blocks her everywhere. Now, dutchbook this!
In most contexts, yes. However, in the sort of dath ilanian context I was going for, or even in the context of a serious group of rationalists in our universe who are longtime friends, I don’t think what you described is a more realistic or rational outcome.
Alice: Ha ha, what a sucker Bob is! I offered him free money, given his stated beliefs, and he turned it down! I win!