that we should do things that would help make ISIS’s ideology more dominant in the world
I think this is where you misunderstood me. I never claimed, nor do I believe that European politicians / European media promote that “we should help make ISIS’s ideology more dominant”. I was only talking about general mainstream Muslim culture which is promoted. And of course, the ideology of ISIS is very different from the mainstream Muslim culture, but I would guess that from a utilitarian point of view it might benefit ISIS if Europe had a mainstream Muslim culture rather than a non-Muslim culture.
I was only talking about general mainstream Muslim culture which is promoted.
Well, again, if you are saying that “left-leaning political elites” are promoting Muslim culture or openly encouraging it to be promoted, then I still simply don’t believe you.
I dare say it’s true that ISIS would prefer a mainstream Muslim Europe to a mostly Christian and secular Europe, and that it would generally prefer a more-Muslim Europe to a less-Muslim Europe. (Though … I wonder how true that is; they might actually prefer an aggressively anti-Muslim Europe with which they could have a glorious fight ending in the domination of ISIS-style Islam.) But a process whose best-case-for-ISIS outcome is a mainstream Muslim Europe in several decades (personally I think even that is a ludicrously paranoid scenario, but I hope we can at least agree that it’s the most ISIS could reasonably hope for from those “left-leaning political elites”) cannot possibly make it unnecessary for ISIS to act more drastically to spread their ideology.
they might actually prefer an aggressively anti-Muslim Europe with which they could have a glorious fight ending in the domination of ISIS-style Islam.
If you treat ISIS as a millennial cult, they expect an apocalyptic scenario where Europe/West are the bad guys with which they need to have an end-of-the-world battle. If the bad guys don’t show up, ISIS will be very disappointed :-/
I think this is where you misunderstood me. I never claimed, nor do I believe that European politicians / European media promote that “we should help make ISIS’s ideology more dominant”. I was only talking about general mainstream Muslim culture which is promoted. And of course, the ideology of ISIS is very different from the mainstream Muslim culture, but I would guess that from a utilitarian point of view it might benefit ISIS if Europe had a mainstream Muslim culture rather than a non-Muslim culture.
Well, again, if you are saying that “left-leaning political elites” are promoting Muslim culture or openly encouraging it to be promoted, then I still simply don’t believe you.
I dare say it’s true that ISIS would prefer a mainstream Muslim Europe to a mostly Christian and secular Europe, and that it would generally prefer a more-Muslim Europe to a less-Muslim Europe. (Though … I wonder how true that is; they might actually prefer an aggressively anti-Muslim Europe with which they could have a glorious fight ending in the domination of ISIS-style Islam.) But a process whose best-case-for-ISIS outcome is a mainstream Muslim Europe in several decades (personally I think even that is a ludicrously paranoid scenario, but I hope we can at least agree that it’s the most ISIS could reasonably hope for from those “left-leaning political elites”) cannot possibly make it unnecessary for ISIS to act more drastically to spread their ideology.
No, the recruitment strategy of ISIS depends on Muslims not having a peaceful space in European culture.
If you treat ISIS as a millennial cult, they expect an apocalyptic scenario where Europe/West are the bad guys with which they need to have an end-of-the-world battle. If the bad guys don’t show up, ISIS will be very disappointed :-/