Why can’t a vocaloid have a personality? Does Gregory House have a personality?
I think the idea of “Miku” is a stand in for a large group of people, just like “Google” is. I also don’t think many people have a problem with personifying Google.
Why can’t a vocaloid have a personality? Does Gregory House have a personality?
Gregory House is the main character of a TV show that has actual plots. Vocaloids are just animesque moeblobs.
Furthermore, Gregory House is not credited for programmatically singing songs actually written and composed by humans.
I think the idea of “Miku” is a stand in for a large group of people, just like “Google” is.
Except people don’t treat it that way. In any case, our senses don’t work that way. If it’s anthropomorphized (pointlessly, in this case), we automatically think of it as having the qualities of a person, whether it makes sense or not.
Gregory House is not credited for programmatically singing songs actually written and composed by humans.
His actor, Hugh Laurie, is credited for performing lines written by different humans. Why does Hugh Laurie deserve performing credit when Miku doesn’t?
Why can’t a vocaloid have a personality? Does Gregory House have a personality?
I think the idea of “Miku” is a stand in for a large group of people, just like “Google” is. I also don’t think many people have a problem with personifying Google.
Gregory House is the main character of a TV show that has actual plots. Vocaloids are just animesque moeblobs.
Furthermore, Gregory House is not credited for programmatically singing songs actually written and composed by humans.
Except people don’t treat it that way. In any case, our senses don’t work that way. If it’s anthropomorphized (pointlessly, in this case), we automatically think of it as having the qualities of a person, whether it makes sense or not.
His actor, Hugh Laurie, is credited for performing lines written by different humans. Why does Hugh Laurie deserve performing credit when Miku doesn’t?
Because Laurie is a person?
Yes, that is the reason.
The question is whether and why we should consider Miku a non-person. I was attempting to refute the proposed personhood predicate implementation.