Obviously some people have made money trading stocks. Does the EMH simply mean that less than 50% of people who trade stocks make money? That doesn’t seem to support the grandiose conclusions that are usually made on the basis of the EMH.
Yeah exactly—for example, something like 90% of active fund managers (professional investors with all the bells and whistles) fail to beat their benchmark, and those that do are highly unlikely to repeat the feat the next year. It makes no difference to me that EMH doesn’t cash out in some kind of precise formula—it just seems like a super useful and interesting thing to know. Sorry if we’ve been talking at cross-purposes!
Yeah exactly—for example, something like 90% of active fund managers (professional investors with all the bells and whistles) fail to beat their benchmark, and those that do are highly unlikely to repeat the feat the next year. It makes no difference to me that EMH doesn’t cash out in some kind of precise formula—it just seems like a super useful and interesting thing to know. Sorry if we’ve been talking at cross-purposes!