I decided to collect the stuff about these recent updates that confuse me, and when added together two were in the shape of a theory!
“Dumbledore was quite correct,” Professor Quirrell said, shaking his head as though in wonderment. “He was also an utter fool to leave the Hogwarts Map in the possession of those two idiots. I had an unpleasant shock after I recovered the Map; it showed my name and yours correctly! The Weasley idiots had thought it a mere malfunction, especially after you received your Cloak and your Time-Turner. If Dumbledore had kept the Map himself—if the Weasleys had ever spoken of it to Dumbledore—but they did not, thankfully.”
Even Quirrell is confused! Wow!
So… Dumbledore did know all along, just like cannon, and sent the map to the twins for plausible deniability. He can get away with that because he doesn’t mind when people think him a fool. And he really needs Querrellmort to think of him as ignorant so he will play the role perfectly… well Voldemort said he could play chess.
In the last thread roystgnr wrote
Harry figures out Quirrell’s identity almost immediately after Snape casts some sort of “Dispel Magical Confusion”, yet the only character who would have the knowledge and incentive to magically confuse Harry about this is Quirrell himself, who seems to be incapable of directly using magic on Harry or Harry’s magic.
That is totally something I wouldn’t have figured out on my own. Well, the first part. I had just put that up to Harry not wanting to see ill of his friend, but magical obfuscation makes sense too. Oh, but someone else had the knowledge if the first theory is right. Someone who used Legilimancy on Harry in chapter 19 and that’s just when Harry found out about it!
So… Dumbledore did know all along, just like cannon, and sent the map to the twins for plausible deniability. He can get away with that because he doesn’t mind when people think him a fool.
That’s mixes well with the idea that the Goblet of Fire kills Voldemort if he takes the stone. It’s simply a well set up trap and because Voldemort thinks he’s smarter than the rest he walks into it.
If Dumbledore had kept the Map himself—if the Weasleys had ever spoken of it to Dumbledore—but they did not, thankfully.
Calling out explicitly why this is confusing:
The trapdoor had hardly slammed shut above them before all nearby sounds muted and the old wizard spun on them and held out a hand and commanded, “Give me the map!”
“M-map?” said Fred or George in total shock. They’d never even suspected that Dumbledore suspected. “Why, w-we don’t know what you’re—”
“Hermione Granger is in trouble,” said the old wizard.
“The Map is in our dorm,” George or Fred said immediately. “Just give us a few minutes to get it and we’ll—”
The wizard’s arms swept them up as if they were hugging-pillows, there was a piercing cry and a flash of fire and then the three of them were in the third-year Gryffindor’s boys’ dorm.
The Weasleys quite definitely told the location of the map to a Phoenix wielding, sorting hat summoning, line of Merlin holding person who looks like Dumbledore. So either Quirrell is lying, or someone Obliviated the Weasleys before Quirrell stole the map from them. Further, Harry knows this.
If the enemy can notice you running off to consult the Weasley twins during class after Hermione was arrested, and find out about that magic map you said was stolen, then the enemy can wonder why I was guarding Hermione Granger’s body.
By the way, that line was edited. It originally read:
If the enemy can notice you running off to consult the Weasley twins during class after Hermione was arrested, and find out about their magic map and steal it, then they can wonder why I was guarding Hermione Granger’s body.
From discussion context, I believe the line was edited because it wasn’t clear how Harry could have learned about the map on his own and people were theorizing that Harry stole it himself.
I decided to collect the stuff about these recent updates that confuse me, and when added together two were in the shape of a theory!
Even Quirrell is confused! Wow!
So… Dumbledore did know all along, just like cannon, and sent the map to the twins for plausible deniability. He can get away with that because he doesn’t mind when people think him a fool. And he really needs Querrellmort to think of him as ignorant so he will play the role perfectly… well Voldemort said he could play chess.
In the last thread roystgnr wrote
That is totally something I wouldn’t have figured out on my own. Well, the first part. I had just put that up to Harry not wanting to see ill of his friend, but magical obfuscation makes sense too. Oh, but someone else had the knowledge if the first theory is right. Someone who used Legilimancy on Harry in chapter 19 and that’s just when Harry found out about it!
That’s mixes well with the idea that the Goblet of Fire kills Voldemort if he takes the stone. It’s simply a well set up trap and because Voldemort thinks he’s smarter than the rest he walks into it.
Calling out explicitly why this is confusing:
The Weasleys quite definitely told the location of the map to a Phoenix wielding, sorting hat summoning, line of Merlin holding person who looks like Dumbledore. So either Quirrell is lying, or someone Obliviated the Weasleys before Quirrell stole the map from them. Further, Harry knows this.
By the way, that line was edited. It originally read:
From discussion context, I believe the line was edited because it wasn’t clear how Harry could have learned about the map on his own and people were theorizing that Harry stole it himself.
‘it’ in Quirrell’s rant is the true name dealio, not the Maurauder’s Map.