A new air purifier is $150, but mine have been hanging around my house collecting dust and viruses; I don’t think a used air purifier would have gone for $150 pre-emergency. Let’s say the used value was $75. To get the same benefit as selling for $300 with no surcharge I’d need to charge $525: 2x my $300, less the $75 used value.
But I agree: the air purifiers situation is still improved when moving from the status quo (illegal) to the proposal (taxed). My point with that footnote is that the proposal still does some to discourage supply increases relative to a world without this regulation.
A new air purifier is $150, but mine have been hanging around my house collecting dust and viruses; I don’t think a used air purifier would have gone for $150 pre-emergency. Let’s say the used value was $75. To get the same benefit as selling for $300 with no surcharge I’d need to charge $525: 2x my $300, less the $75 used value.
But I agree: the air purifiers situation is still improved when moving from the status quo (illegal) to the proposal (taxed). My point with that footnote is that the proposal still does some to discourage supply increases relative to a world without this regulation.