One advantage of using something unique to our community, like cartographer, is that it doesn’t have any pre-formed associations in epistemology or science. If we use it consistently and well, there is always a chance it will catch on more broadly.
To counteract the inclusiveness it might bring (e.g. Rattlers vs. Eagles at RobbersCave), we can make an effort to honorarily induct others doing good work. Greg Mankiw did a good job marketing the Pigou Club by identifying those with similar views to him.
One advantage of using something unique to our community, like cartographer, is that it doesn’t have any pre-formed associations in epistemology or science. If we use it consistently and well, there is always a chance it will catch on more broadly.
To counteract the inclusiveness it might bring (e.g. Rattlers vs. Eagles at Robbers Cave), we can make an effort to honorarily induct others doing good work. Greg Mankiw did a good job marketing the Pigou Club by identifying those with similar views to him.