It’s not at all clear that improving the other person’s opinion was really one of Eliezer’s goals on this occasion, as opposed to showing up the other person’s intellectual inferiority. He called the post “Bayesian Judo”, and highlighted how his showing-off impressed someone of the opposite sex.
He does also suggest that in the end he and the other person came to some sort of agreement—but it seems pretty clear that the thing they agreed on had little to do with the claim the other guy had originally been making, and that the other guy’s opinion on that didn’t actually change. So I think an accurate, though arguably unkind, summary of “Bayesian Judo” goes like this: “I was at a party, I got into an argument with a religious guy who didn’t believe AI was possible, I overwhelmed him with my superior knowledge and intelligence, he submitted to my manifest superiority, and the whole performance impressed a woman”. On this occasion, helping the other party to have better opinions doesn’t seem to have been a high priority.
It’s not at all clear that improving the other person’s opinion was really one of Eliezer’s goals on this occasion, as opposed to showing up the other person’s intellectual inferiority. He called the post “Bayesian Judo”, and highlighted how his showing-off impressed someone of the opposite sex.
He does also suggest that in the end he and the other person came to some sort of agreement—but it seems pretty clear that the thing they agreed on had little to do with the claim the other guy had originally been making, and that the other guy’s opinion on that didn’t actually change. So I think an accurate, though arguably unkind, summary of “Bayesian Judo” goes like this: “I was at a party, I got into an argument with a religious guy who didn’t believe AI was possible, I overwhelmed him with my superior knowledge and intelligence, he submitted to my manifest superiority, and the whole performance impressed a woman”. On this occasion, helping the other party to have better opinions doesn’t seem to have been a high priority.