You have entirely missed the point I was making in that comment.
Of course I am aware of the standard form of the joke. I presented my modified form of the joke in the linked comment, as a deliberate contrast with the standard form, to illustrate the point I was making.
Actually, there is a logical error in your mathematicians joke—at least compared to how this joke normally goes. When it’s their turn, the 3rd mathematician knows that the first two wanted a beer (otherwise they would have said “yes”), and so can say Yes/No. https://www.beingamathematician.org/Jokes/445-three-logicians-walk-into-a-bar.png
You have entirely missed the point I was making in that comment.
Of course I am aware of the standard form of the joke. I presented my modified form of the joke in the linked comment, as a deliberate contrast with the standard form, to illustrate the point I was making.