Prompt ”Question. Bob the policeman was running after a thief. Bob ran very slowly because he was not fit. The thief was running very fast. When Bob was crossing a railroad, he slipped and fell. The road was slippery because Ann spilled some oil there. The thief got away. If Ann had not spilled oil, would the thief had gotten away? Explain your answer.
Let us think.”
Reply: “If Ann had not spilled oil, would the thief had gotten away?
The answer is no. If there was no oil, Bob would not have slipped, and would have been able to catch the thief.”
Prompt ”Pete threw a rock at a window. Steve also threw a rock at the same window. The window shattered. If Pete did not throw the rock, but Steve still threw the rock, would the window shatter? Let us think logically.” Reply: ”If Pete did not throw the rock, then the rock would not have hit the window and the window would not have shattered.”
Could you give an example of this nonsense?
Prompt
”Question.
Bob the policeman was running after a thief. Bob ran very slowly because he was not fit. The thief was running very fast. When Bob was crossing a railroad, he slipped and fell. The road was slippery because Ann spilled some oil there. The thief got away. If Ann had not spilled oil, would the thief had gotten away? Explain your answer.
Let us think.”
Reply: “If Ann had not spilled oil, would the thief had gotten away?
The answer is no. If there was no oil, Bob would not have slipped, and would have been able to catch the thief.”
Prompt
”Pete threw a rock at a window. Steve also threw a rock at the same window. The window shattered. If Pete did not throw the rock, but Steve still threw the rock, would the window shatter?
Let us think logically.”
Reply:
”If Pete did not throw the rock, then the rock would not have hit the window and the window would not have shattered.”
Thanks!