Error theorists believe that when people say “Murder is wrong”, those people are actually trying to claim that it is a fact that murder has the property of being wrong. However, those people are incorrect (error theorists think) because Murder does not have the property of being wrong—because nothing has the property of being wrong.
It’s not about whether or not there are buckets—error theory just says that most people think there is stuff in buckets, but they’re incorrect.
However, those people are wrong (error theorists think) because Murder does not have the property of being wrong—because nothing has the property of being wrong.
I smell a peculiar odour of inconsistency.
(That means, add some modifier, as “morally”, to the second “wrong”, else it sounds really weird.)
Error theorists believe that when people say “Murder is wrong”, those people are actually trying to claim that it is a fact that murder has the property of being wrong. However, those people are incorrect (error theorists think) because Murder does not have the property of being wrong—because nothing has the property of being wrong.
It’s not about whether or not there are buckets—error theory just says that most people think there is stuff in buckets, but they’re incorrect.
I smell a peculiar odour of inconsistency.
(That means, add some modifier, as “morally”, to the second “wrong”, else it sounds really weird.)
Exactly.