I went back to the beginning of this series of posts, and found this introduction:
I think I must now temporarily digress from the sequence on zombies (which was a digression from the discussion of reductionism, which was a digression from the Mind Projection Fallacy) in order to discuss quantum mechanics. The reasons why this belongs in the middle of a discussion on zombies in the middle of a discussion of reductionism in the middle of a discussion of the Mind Projection Fallacy, will become apparent eventually.
Eliezer, would you mind telling us the reasons now, instead of having them become apparent eventually? I ask this because I’d like to know, if I detect some error or confusion in the posts or comments, whether it’s central to your eventual point, or if it’s just an inconsequential nit. Do you actually need Barbour’s timeless physics to make your point, or would the standard block universe do? I’d like to skip explaining the difference between the two if the difference doesn’t really matter. I mean we’re not here to learn about some speculative physics for its own sake...
I went back to the beginning of this series of posts, and found this introduction:
I think I must now temporarily digress from the sequence on zombies (which was a digression from the discussion of reductionism, which was a digression from the Mind Projection Fallacy) in order to discuss quantum mechanics. The reasons why this belongs in the middle of a discussion on zombies in the middle of a discussion of reductionism in the middle of a discussion of the Mind Projection Fallacy, will become apparent eventually.
Eliezer, would you mind telling us the reasons now, instead of having them become apparent eventually? I ask this because I’d like to know, if I detect some error or confusion in the posts or comments, whether it’s central to your eventual point, or if it’s just an inconsequential nit. Do you actually need Barbour’s timeless physics to make your point, or would the standard block universe do? I’d like to skip explaining the difference between the two if the difference doesn’t really matter. I mean we’re not here to learn about some speculative physics for its own sake...