I’m not 100% sure what your S means, but I don’t think it’s true.
If Omega comes along and says “If you want, I’ll make a 1m cube of gold somewhere you’ll never observe it, and then make you forget all about this offer”, then P will accept.
On the other hand, P wouldn’t necessarily accept an offer to make him delusionally believe that a cube of gold exists.
That is true, but not relevant to the point I am trying to make. If P took the first offer, they would end up exactly as well off as if they hadn’t received the offer, and if P took the second offer, they would end up better off. The fact that P’s beliefs don’t correspond with reality does not change this. The reason that P would accept the first offer but not the second is that P believes the universe would be “better” with the cube. P does not think ey will actually be happier (or whatever) accepting offer 1, and if P does think ey will be happier, I think that is an error in moral judgment. The error is in thinking that the box is morally relevant, when it cannot be, since P is the only morally relevant thing in this universe.
I’m not 100% sure what your S means, but I don’t think it’s true.
If Omega comes along and says “If you want, I’ll make a 1m cube of gold somewhere you’ll never observe it, and then make you forget all about this offer”, then P will accept.
On the other hand, P wouldn’t necessarily accept an offer to make him delusionally believe that a cube of gold exists.
That is true, but not relevant to the point I am trying to make. If P took the first offer, they would end up exactly as well off as if they hadn’t received the offer, and if P took the second offer, they would end up better off. The fact that P’s beliefs don’t correspond with reality does not change this. The reason that P would accept the first offer but not the second is that P believes the universe would be “better” with the cube. P does not think ey will actually be happier (or whatever) accepting offer 1, and if P does think ey will be happier, I think that is an error in moral judgment. The error is in thinking that the box is morally relevant, when it cannot be, since P is the only morally relevant thing in this universe.