Thanks! It looks like you’re right. This is bizarre, Shalizi says accent is “highly heritable”, yet in another post he explains that estimated heritability of accent will be quite low if you measure it properly (see the section “Cultural transmission”). Edited my comment.
Shalizi’s usage seems perfectly reasonable to me. People use the phrase “highly heritable” to refer to the experiments they actually do, not to the theoretically best experiments they could do. Shalizi claims that performing the same experiments with accent would yield a conclusion of “heritable.” (though he backs off of “highly” and is generally evasive about quantity)
Thanks! It looks like you’re right. This is bizarre, Shalizi says accent is “highly heritable”, yet in another post he explains that estimated heritability of accent will be quite low if you measure it properly (see the section “Cultural transmission”). Edited my comment.
Shalizi’s usage seems perfectly reasonable to me. People use the phrase “highly heritable” to refer to the experiments they actually do, not to the theoretically best experiments they could do. Shalizi claims that performing the same experiments with accent would yield a conclusion of “heritable.” (though he backs off of “highly” and is generally evasive about quantity)