I would expect a 30-year old dog to be as fertile as it is generally healthy. In other words, I expect fertility not to decline much sooner than the rest of the body. If it does, we recognize it as something special, like the menopause.
There’s a problem predicting purely from theory. No single component or function (whether fertility or something else) would normally age faster than the others, because evolution would select against that. But if a crucial function like fertility stopped working after a certain age and there weren’t any selectable variants that kept it working longer, then animals that lived longer but were infertile wouldn’t have a much greater fitness than those who died as soon as they became infertile, and we would see the same result—animals being fertile roughly as long as they live.
If … there weren’t any selectable variants that ….
Exactly- There have never been selectable variants that are immortal (or even nearly so). Whether that is because immortality is hard (unlikely to result from random drift) or not is irrelevant for the purposes of natural selection if it never happens.
I would expect a 30-year old dog to be as fertile as it is generally healthy. In other words, I expect fertility not to decline much sooner than the rest of the body. If it does, we recognize it as something special, like the menopause.
There’s a problem predicting purely from theory. No single component or function (whether fertility or something else) would normally age faster than the others, because evolution would select against that. But if a crucial function like fertility stopped working after a certain age and there weren’t any selectable variants that kept it working longer, then animals that lived longer but were infertile wouldn’t have a much greater fitness than those who died as soon as they became infertile, and we would see the same result—animals being fertile roughly as long as they live.
Exactly- There have never been selectable variants that are immortal (or even nearly so). Whether that is because immortality is hard (unlikely to result from random drift) or not is irrelevant for the purposes of natural selection if it never happens.